6/13/2009

Opportunists, not Omnivores


It's garden season again and while we don't have much we can eat yet, there are tidbits here and there that keep us on our toes, just enough to hold us over until the bountiful harvest rolls in. Amos, of course, is loving the fact and now that our plants are big enough to withstand it if he accidentally steps on them, he is able to come down with me for the grueling tasks of weeding, tilling, and general plant upkeep, as well as checking on our budding vegetables and fruits. Yesterday, to my dismay, a zucchini I'd been anticipating picking was ruined by the torrential rains the day before and was complete mush from laying on the soppy ground and then baking in the hot sun. Another smaller one had been halfway ruined too so I picked it off and tossed it out of the fence. Now you may be thinking by now, "What does ANY of this have to do with raw feeding?!" Relax, I'm setting the scene first. ;) So I continue my work, meanwhile, Amos is staring at the half rotten squash across the fence. I gave in and went and got it for him, breaking off the slimy half and giving him the good half to munch on. After his zucchini he foraged around and picked a raspberry and we went back inside. So, doesn't this seem a bit hypocritical that I am so passionate about feeding a raw prey model diet and yet I'm giving my dog vegetables and fruit? To some it may but let me delve deeper into the topic.

Wolves, and our domestic wolves, by design, are carnivores. There is scientific evidence concluding this to be true, so let's set that aside. Both are also opportunistic which essentially means if it's available and edible, and the wolf or dog is hungry, he's going to eat it. It's a spectacular survival plan. Now, that plant matter is coming out pretty much the same way it went in and there may be a ***slight*** bit of nutrition from it but by no means is it something I would consider beneficial.

The dictionary defines opportunist as "the policy or practice, as in politics, business, or one's personal affairs, of adapting actions, decisions, etc., to expediency or effectiveness regardless of the sacrifice of ethical principles." To apply that to our topic, I'd rewrite that definition as "the practice of adapting actions, diet, etc., for survival, regardless of the sacrifice of what is normal or natural for that species."
Now, while I do not advocate plant matter forming a part of the normal diet for a carnivore, there are times when I am going to let my dog exercise his opportunism and if he'd like to eat some mulberries that have fallen on the ground while I am picking then that's his CHOICE. Empowerment is a part of having a healthful life. I find it very different than purposely handing him a carrot or a tomato. He'll eat it because he's hungry but it is not the same as if he decided to seek it out himself. When he chooses what he wants to eat, often times he'll forage a few berries and be done. Sometimes he gorges himself until his poop is purple. Either is fine with me. I find that letting him decide is much more rewarding than what he ends up eating. In fall and winter when the fruits and vegetables are for the most part dead, that ends his foraging. It's completely dependent on the environment and seasons, like if he were a wolf and had only himself to depend on for food. Most people say "Fido loves blueberries/lettuce/peas/whatever so he must need vegetables and fruits to be healthy." Well Fido also LOVES to eat cat poop out of the litterpans so should he be getting a generous serving of that too in his bowl? Of course not! Opportunism at work here, folks! If you want to give your dog a carrot stick once in awhile then go for it, but understand he's eating it because he's opportunistic, not because he's an omnivore. To read more, visit the Dogs Are Carnivores link on the right side of the page.

5 comments:

  1. Lovely post! Glad to see you blogging again!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm trying to get back in the swing of things. Glad to see people are still checking back here. :D Makes me feel like I'm not writing to myself!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, no, I send people to your blog all the time! I have put it in with my "usual" basic raw feeding linkys.
    Am sending people to the new raw feeding forum, too. Posted there myself.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Heather, Awesome post. I have one opportunistic beagle, Marvin, who will happily gorge himself on berries until his poo is purple for two days. The other one, not so much ... he's content being as carnivorous as possible.

    These are great photos of Amos. He's so adorable!

    I finally took videos of my boys eating their first oxtail. I just have to get around to posting them on the blog!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Heather, I also agree with your commenters , Awesome post.

    These are great photos of Amos. He's so adorable!

    ReplyDelete